girl on the phone panicked standing beside her wrecked car

Dealing with injuries from a car accident someone else caused can feel like a long, uphill battle. The pain and stress of recovery are challenging enough without the added frustration of dealing with insurance companies like Allstate. Unfortunately, Allstate, like many insurers, prioritize minimizing payouts over providing fair compensation, often using tactics designed to make the claims process needlessly difficult and overwhelming. Arguably, Allstate might be one of the most difficult insurance companies to deal with.

This is where a personal injury attorney can help. Knowing how Joye Law Firm lawyers handle an Allstate injury claim gives you insight into what it takes to push back against these tactics and pursue the compensation you deserve. A skilled attorney can take on the complexities of the insurance claim process, allowing you to focus on your recovery while they fight for your best outcome. Contact a Joye Law Firm car accident lawyer near you today for a free consultation.

Allstate’s Approach to Personal Injury Claims

Insurance companies like Allstate often have well-established processes for handling personal injury claims. While it may seem straightforward, these processes are designed to protect the insurer’s bottom line, not the injured party’s rights. Recognizing how these systems operate is the first step in preparing for the challenges ahead.

Allstate uses data-driven models and aggressive negotiation strategies to evaluate claims. Adjusters may rely on software programs to calculate settlement offers, often undervaluing injuries and losses in the process. While these tools help streamline claims on their end, they often fail to account for the true impact of an accident on someone’s life. This is often referred to as “non-economic damages”, which an insurance company usually doesn’t take into consideration – until you hire a lawyer to fight on your behalf.

Tactics to Minimize Payouts

Adjusters may act friendly and understanding, but their primary goal is to save the company money. They might:

  • Offer quick, low settlements in hopes you’ll accept before fully understanding the extent of your injuries.
  • Request unnecessary medical records to delay the process or find reasons to dispute your claim.
  • Downplay the severity of your injuries or argue pre-existing conditions are to blame.

Knowing these strategies helps attorneys anticipate and counteract them effectively.

The Role of a Personal Injury Lawyer

Handling an Allstate injury claim without legal representation can feel like going up against a giant. Insurance companies have extensive resources to fight claims brought against their policyholders, but a skilled personal injury lawyer helps even the playing field. Here are the advantages of legal representation:

Comprehensive Case Evaluation:

A thorough case evaluation involves estimating the value of your claim. Lawyers consider not just current expenses like medical bills and lost wages but also long-term costs, such as rehabilitation and ongoing impact on your daily life. At Joye Law Firm, we meet as a team to discuss all cases to ensure that every client benefits from more than 300 years of combined legal experience between our attorneys.

Gathering Evidence:

Lawyers might visit the accident scene, review surveillance footage, and consult with accident reconstruction specialists. They also work closely with clients to meticulously document medical treatments, bills, prescriptions, and therapy sessions, ensuring the full impact of the injury is clearly demonstrated. Every piece of evidence strengthens the case.

Establishing Liability

Proving fault means connecting the at-fault driver’s actions to the cause of the crash. This might include showing they violated traffic laws, ignored road conditions, or acted negligently in some other way. Establishing liability leaves little room for Allstate to dispute its responsibility.

Negotiating with Allstate

An attorney’s primary role is to safeguard your rights and advocate your best interest during the claims process. They handle communication with Allstate, ensuring adjusters don’t twist your words or use them against you. By stepping into this role, your attorney will:

  • Present a clear, well-documented case that demonstrates the value of your claim. Attorneys use medical records, evidence, and expert opinions to build a compelling argument for higher compensation.
  • Push back when an adjuster presents a low settlement with evidence and counterarguments. This process often involves several rounds of negotiation, but persistence can lead to better results.
  • Rely on a combination of evidence, clear communication, and firm advocacy. They don’t accept inadequate offers and are prepared to escalate the claim if necessary.

When Litigation Becomes Necessary

While most claims settle during negotiations, if Allstate refuses to offer a reasonable settlement, filing a lawsuit can provide additional leverage.  Taking the case to court shows you’re serious about holding them accountable.

Trial preparation involves gathering additional evidence, consulting with experts, and developing a persuasive argument to present in court. Even with a lawsuit filed, many cases settle before reaching the courtroom. However, being ready for court can strengthen your position.

What Happens When Allstate Refuses to Pay Out an Uninsured or Under-Insured Motorist Claim?

If the driver who hit you does not have enough insurance to cover your damages, you may still have options for compensation. In South Carolina, drivers are required to carry uninsured motorist (UM) coverage, which provides up to $25,000 for bodily injury per person and $50,000 per accident. Many drivers also opt for underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage, which offers additional protection when an at-fault driver’s policy falls short.

At Joye Law Firm, we understand how overwhelming this situation can be, and we’re here to help. Our experienced attorneys can:Joye Law Firm Intake Charleston

  1. Review Your Policy and Denial
    We’ll analyze your Allstate policy and the reasons they’ve given for denying or underpaying your claim. With our knowledge of South Carolina insurance laws, we’ll identify if Allstate is acting unfairly or in bad faith.
  2. Build a Compelling Case
    Our team will gather evidence such as accident reports, medical records, expert opinions, and witness statements to create a strong, well-documented case that demonstrates the value of your claim.
  3. Handle All Communication with Allstate
    Joye Law Firm will manage all communication with Allstate, ensuring they don’t twist your words or use them against you. We’ll advocate for your rights and push back against lowball settlement offers with evidence and counterarguments.
  4. Challenge Unfair Denials or Offers
    If Allstate denies your UM/UIM claim or refuses to pay what you deserve, we’ll dispute their decision and fight for a fair settlement. If necessary, we’ll file a complaint with the South Carolina Department of Insurance to hold them accountable.
  5. Escalate When Necessary
    When negotiations fail, we’re ready to escalate your claim. Whether through mediation, arbitration, or filing a lawsuit for breach of contract or bad faith, Joye Law Firm will fight tirelessly to secure the compensation you deserve.

Don’t let Allstate’s refusal to pay leave you without the resources you need to recover. Trust Joye Law Firm to stand by your side, protect your rights, and fight for the compensation you’re entitled to under your policy.

The Importance of Client Communication Throughout the Process

A successful claim depends on open and consistent communication between the lawyer and the client. Lawyers provide updates at every stage, ensuring you always know where your claim stands. Regular communication helps build trust and keeps you in the loop.

Legal terms and procedures can feel unfamiliar. A good lawyer will take the time to explain everything in clear, simple terms and will help break things down in plain language so you understand what’s happening and why. Your attorney is also there to address your questions or worries. They can offer guidance and reassurance every step of the way.

Why Choose Joye Law Firm for Your Allstate Injury Claim

Since 1968, Joye Law Firm has been dedicated to helping South Carolinians recover after life-changing accidents. We understand how to push back against big insurance companies like Allstate and advocate for the compensation you deserve. Our team’s combined 300+ years of legal experience ensures that every client receives skilled representation and personalized attention.

Additional Benefits of Working with Joye Law Firm

  • Dedicated to Your Recovery: Your well-being is our priority. Our lawyers handle every case with care, determination, and focus on the details that make a difference. We fight tirelessly to secure the best results for our clients.
  • A Trusted Name in the Community: As a firm deeply rooted in the South Carolina communities we serve, we’ve built a reputation for integrity and effective advocacy. Recognized by organizations like Best Lawyers, Joye Law Firm has earned a spot among the top personal injury firms in the state.
  • No Fee Guarantee: We work on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay no fees upfront and owe nothing unless we win your case. Our fees come as a percentage of the compensation we recover, aligning our success with yours.

Contact a Personal Injury Attorney Now

Don’t let Allstate take advantage of your situation. Reach out to Joye Law Firm for a free consultation today. We’re here to listen to your story, evaluate your case, and fight for the compensation you deserve. Let us take the burden of the claims process off your shoulders so you can focus on moving forward.

About the Author

Robert Howell is an attorney with Joye Law Firm. He represents people who have been injured in motor vehicle accidents or sustained serious injuries in slip and fall accidentsdog attacks, or other premises liability accidents. He also represents injured workers in South Carolina who need help pursuing workers’ compensation benefits after an on-the-job injury.

“I’ve always wanted to help others who couldn’t help themselves.”

Recent Blog Post
Man being breathalyzed
What is Dram Shop Liability in South Carolina?

Alcohol-related accidents lead to devastating consequences, and holding the right parties accountable is crucial for justice. Dram shop and social host liability laws in South Carolina are designed to do just that. These laws hold businesses and individuals responsible when they…

man driving in bad weather
7 Tips for Driving in Bad Weather This Winter

As temperatures begin to drop across South Carolina from Clinton and Columbia to Charleston and Myrtle Beach, the probability increases of hazardous road conditions and weather-related car accidents. Traditionally, South Carolina doesn’t get much snow. However, the January 3, 2018…

What to do in South Carolina? Events for the week of January 21-27, 2025 in Charleston, Summerville, Columbia, Myrtle Beach, and Upstate SC.
What to Do in South Carolina: Joye Law Firm Staff Picks 1/21/25 – 1/27/25

    South Carolina has something special for everyone this week, whether you’re a foodie, music lover, sports enthusiast, or dog lover. The Joye Law Firm team has rounded up some of the most exciting events happening across the state….

What to do in South Carolina? Events for the week of January 14-20, 2025 in Charleston, Summerville, Columbia, Myrtle Beach, and Upstate SC.
What to Do in South Carolina: Joye Law Firm Staff Picks 1/14/25 – 1/20/25

  This week, South Carolina offers a fantastic lineup of events that promise fun, laughter, and unique experiences. Whether you’re exploring history in Charleston, enjoying comedy in Columbia, or savoring seafood in Summerville, there’s something for everyone. Check out what…

Awards & Recognition
Media
ABC
NBC
Fox
CBS News
ESPN Radio logo