On This page
    car accident with a tire blow out

    Tires are the only point of contact between your vehicle and the road, making their reliability critical for your safety.

    When a tire is manufactured or installed with a defect, the risks of a serious accident escalate quickly, often with little warning. From sudden blowouts to loss of control, car accidents caused by defective tires are unexpected and often catastrophic.

    Understanding the role a defective part plays in accidents is beneficial for anyone who has experienced a tire-related crash. If you suspect a defective tire caused or worsened your crash, it’s important to have an experienced personal injury lawyer evaluate your case. Our firm has firsthand experience dealing with these types of crashes.

    We represented the family of a young man who was killed in a crash caused by a bad tire. The “new” tire that was installed on the vehicle by a tire shop was actually dangerously old and deteriorating. The same day the tire was installed, it de-treaded causing a deadly rollover accident.

    We also helped a client when her journey to Miami turned tragic when defective Firestone tires on her Mazda Navajo caused a rollover accident on I-95, leaving her with fractured cervical vertebrae and a lifetime of medical challenges. With the help of Joye Law Firm and firm partner Mark Joye, she secured a significant settlement, marking one of the two largest settlements among the Firestone cases filed in South Carolina.

    Defective tire cases are complex, but we have the knowledge and resources to investigate thoroughly and hold negligent manufacturers or installers accountable. Contact us today for a free consultation and take the first step toward securing the compensation and justice you deserve.

    Common Tire Defects Leading to Accidents

    Defective tires create serious hazards for drivers, often without warning. These issues range from structural weaknesses to design flaws, and each defect brings risks. Recognizing these common problems helps drivers recognize potential dangers before accidents occur.

    Tread separation

    When the tread separates from the tire, it throws off the vehicle’s balance, causing sudden handling issues. This defect often leads to a total loss of control, especially at higher speeds, and can make it impossible to navigate the road safely.

    Blowouts

    Blowouts occur when a tire suddenly bursts, leaving the driver struggling to maintain control. Blowouts frequently happen at high speeds, which increases the likelihood of a crash. The immediate loss of air pressure also makes it difficult to brake or steer properly.

    Sidewall defects

    Cracks, bubbles, or other sidewall weaknesses are another common defect. These issues often lead to tire failure under sharp turns, heavy loads, or rough terrain. Even a tiny defect in the sidewall compromises the tire’s strength and durability.

    Manufacturing errorsflat tire

    Errors during the tire’s production process, such as poor material choices or improper assembly, introduce unseen risks. These defects remain hidden until the tire is pushed to its limits, whether during a long-distance driving or harsh weather conditions, making them particularly dangerous.

    Design flaws

    Some tires are designed poorly. Whether due to improper material selection or flawed tread patterns, these tires wear out quickly or underperform. Drivers relying on them for traction, braking, or durability may find themselves in dangerous situations when the tire doesn’t deliver.

    Each defect poses unique dangers, but the result is the same—reduced control and an increased risk of accidents. Staying informed about potential tire issues helps drivers protect themselves and act if they suspect their tires are compromised.

    How Defective Tires Cause Accidents

    Defective tires directly affect vehicle performance, creating dangerous conditions that lead to accidents. When a tire fails, control over the vehicle drops sharply, and the likelihood of a crash rises.

    Loss of control

    A defective tire often causes a sudden loss of control. Tread separation and blowouts throw off the vehicle’s balance, making it hard to steer, especially at high speeds. Drivers can experience swerving, fishtailing, or even rolling over as the vehicle veers unpredictably.

    Skidding and hydroplaning

    Defective tires with poor tread design or wear struggle to grip the road. These tires fail to channel water away on wet surfaces, leading to hydroplaning. When a vehicle hydroplanes, it slides uncontrollably across the road, making braking and steering ineffective.

    Increased stopping distance

    Tires with weak or damaged tread don’t generate enough friction to stop quickly. In an emergency, this increased stopping distance may mean the difference between avoiding an accident and crashing into another vehicle or obstacle.

    Rollovers

    Large vehicles like SUVs are more likely to roll over when a defective tire fails. A blowout or sidewall collapse shifts the vehicle’s center of gravity, tipping it over during sharp turns or evasive maneuvers.

    Each of these situations reduces a driver’s ability to avoid a crash. Defective tires can fail without warning, creating sudden and unpredictable situations that leave drivers with little control and often result in dangerous and unavoidable outcomes.

    Determining Liability in Defective Tire Accidents

    Establishing liability in a defective tire accident involves identifying the responsible party or parties. Multiple factors, from manufacturing defects to improper maintenance, determine who is responsible.

    Manufacturer liability

    When a tire leaves the factory with flaws, the manufacturer often bears responsibility. Defects in design, materials, or production that cause the tire to fail lead to liability.

    If the manufacturer knew or should have known about the defect but failed to address it, they are held accountable for the resulting accidents.

    Retailer liability

    Tire retailers may also be liable if they sell defective products. Retailers are responsible for ensuring the products they sell meet safety standards. If a retailer sells a tire known to be faulty or under recall, they share liability for any accidents caused by that tire.

    Mechanic or installer liability

    Mechanics and tire installers must properly install tires and inspect them for defects. If a mechanic fails to notice or report visible defects during installation or maintenance, the courts may hold them liable for accidents resulting from that negligence.

    Vehicle manufacturer liability

    The manufacturer could be liable if a vehicle’s design or suspension system contributes to premature tire wear or failure, such as when the vehicle’s design places abnormal stress on the tires, leading to dangerous conditions.

    Determining liability in crashes caused by defective tires requires a detailed investigation into the tire’s history, the vehicle’s maintenance, and the parties involved.

    A thorough analysis establishes who is at fault and ensures victims pursue claims against the correct entities.

    Signs Defective Tires Caused Your Accident

    Recognizing the signs that a defective tire caused your accident is crucial for determining liability and pursuing compensation. Several indicators suggest the tire, not driver error or road conditions, led to the crash.

    Unexplained blowouts

    A sudden tire blowout without hitting debris or any obvious cause points to a potential defect. Blowouts typically occur when the tire has a structural weakness, making it prone to sudden failure even under normal driving conditions.

    Tire recalls

    If the tire in your accident has been recalled, it strongly suggests a defect contributed to the crash. Tire manufacturers issue recalls for problems like tread separation, sidewall issues, or design flaws that increase the risk of accidents. Checking recall notices after an accident determines if your tire was defective.

    Abnormal wear patterns

    Uneven or rapid tread wear on a tire signals a potential defect. If you’ve regularly rotated and maintained your tires but still notice abnormal wear, the tire may have a manufacturing or design flaw. This defect compromises traction and handling, increasing the risk of an accident.

    Handling problems before the accident

    If you experienced unusual vibrations, pulling to one side, or difficulty steering before the accident may indicate a defective tire. These symptoms often appear before a major failure, such as tread separation or a blowout, making them warning signs that something is wrong with the tire.

    No external cause

    A defective tire may be to blame if your accident occurred without external causes, such as hitting an obstacle or extreme weather conditions. When there’s no apparent reason for losing control, tire failure becomes a likely suspect.

    Identifying these signs builds a strong case that defective tires caused the accident, which is critical for holding the right party accountable and recovering damages.

    Filing a Claim for Defective Tire AccidentsProduct liability case study

    Filing a claim after a defective tire accident involves several steps to help you secure compensation for your injuries and damages. A structured approach ensures you have the evidence and legal support to build a strong case.

    Steps to take after the accident
    Immediately after the accident, prioritize safety and medical attention. Once safe, document the scene by taking photos of the tire, the vehicle damage, and the road conditions.

    Keep the defective tire, as it is critical evidence in your case. If possible, gather witness statements and contact information. Reporting the accident to law enforcement also creates an official record supporting your claim. In South Carolina filing an FR-10 is mandatory in crashes involving injuries, deaths, or more than $1,000 in property damage.

    How a lawyer helps
    An experienced attorney investigates the cause of the tire failure, gathering necessary evidence like tire recall information, maintenance records, and expert testimony.

    Your lawyer will also determine which party is liable: the tire manufacturer, retailer, or another responsible entity. Your attorney will handle all communication with the at-fault parties, so they can’t try to coerce you into settling for less than you deserve. Legal representation ensures your rights are protected and maximizes your chances of a successful outcome.

    Proving negligence in defective tire cases
    To win a defective tire case, you must prove negligence. This means showing that the responsible party failed to provide a safe product, whether through design flaws, manufacturing errors, or improper installation.

    Your attorney works with experts to analyze the tire and demonstrate how the defect led to the accident. Solid evidence, like the defective tire itself, product recalls, expert testimonies, and witness statements, strengthens your claim.

    Types of Compensation

    A defective tire claim may allow you to recover several types of compensation, including medical expenses, lost wages, property damage, and pain and suffering.

    If the accident resulted in long-term injuries or disability, you could also receive compensation for future medical treatment and loss of earning capacity.

    Filing a defective tire accident claim requires careful documentation, legal guidance, and a clear understanding of your rights. Taking prompt action and consulting a lawyer ensures you secure the compensation you deserve.

    Why Choose Joye Law Firm?

    At Joye Law Firm, we’ve been dedicated to securing justice for accident and injury victims across South Carolina since 1968. With over 300 years of combined legal experience, our injury and product liability attorneys bring deep knowledge and unwavering commitment to every case we handle.

    Selected as South Carolina Super Lawyers and with many attorneys holding leadership positions in state and local legal organizations, our team has built a reputation for delivering real results that help clients regain control of their lives.

    Client-centered representation

    We believe in treating every client with compassion, respect, and courtesy. We understand that you may be facing one of the most challenging and painful moments in your life. That’s why from the moment we start working together, we listen carefully, keep you informed, and promptly respond to your concerns.

    We will work tirelessly to achieve the best possible outcome for you, while ensuring you feel supported and cared for throughout the process.

    Proven results and trust

    We know trust is earned, and we are proud that many of our clients have shared testimonials about the quality of our legal services.

    While every case is different, our commitment to standing up for accident victims never wavers. We fight to ensure you receive the compensation and care you deserve to rebuild your life.

    A deep commitment to the community

    At Joye Law Firm, our dedication extends beyond the courtroom. Through our “Joye in the Community” program, we actively engage with and support local charities, schools, and organizations.

    From our annual scholarship program to donations to non-profits across the state, we believe in giving back to the neighborhoods that have supported us for decades.

    When you choose Joye Law Firm, you’re not just hiring an attorney—you’re gaining a partner who will stand by your side, advocate for your rights, and help you move forward.

    Contact us today for a free consultation, and let our team use its experience and dedication to serve you.

    Contact Us
    Scenes from Joye Law Firm's Columbia office in May of 2024.