Person calls for assistance near two damaged cars after an accident, seeking legal or emergency help.

South Carolina law requires drivers to have car insurance. It’s a financial obligation that often changes without warning. One day, you’re paying the usual amount. The next, your bill is higher. No notice. No clear reason.

These changes are not random. Insurance companies look at more than driving records. The car you drive, where you live, and claims from other people are all relevant.

If your car insurance rates have gone up or you’re worried they will, let’s examine why this has happened and what you can do about it.

Nationwide Accident Trends are Driving Insurance Rate Increases

Rising accident rates nationwide are one key reason for higher auto insurance premiums. More accidents mean more insurance claims, and that cost is passed down to drivers.

Insurance companies like Allstate and Geico have responded to these trends by raising rates.

Several factors contribute to this hike, including:

  • Increased traffic
  • Riskier driving behavior
  • Higher repair costs

South Carolina’s population is booming with more moving to our beautiful state each year. Unfortunately, this leads to busier roads and a higher likelihood of crashes.

Distracted driving due to smartphones and in-car technology is also a growing concern. The more distractions drivers face, the higher the chance of collisions.

The financial impact is clear. More claims mean higher payouts for insurers, and those costs are reflected in the premiums you pay. Staying informed about these industry shifts can help you make smarter decisions about your coverage and costs.

Your driving record

While you may not have any influence over other drivers’ actions or the number of insurance claims filed nationwide, you can control your own driving record.

If your driving record reflects several traffic infractions or car accidents, your premiums will likely be much higher than average.

Your age and gender

Insurance premiums often discriminate against younger people and the male gender because younger male drivers have a higher risk of being in a serious vehicle accident than women and older drivers.

Vehicle make and model

Drivers with expensive vehicles, sports vehicles, or vehicles designed for speed typically pay a higher rate for car insurance than those in less costly, more economical vehicles.

The amount you use your vehicle may also affect your insurance rate—a greater number of miles driven per year means a greater risk of being involved in an accident.

Being in an accident

Your insurance rates will likely increase if you’re at fault for a crash. That’s why it’s critical to challenge fault determinations when they’re unclear or incorrect.

Having a South Carolina car accident attorney on your side can help protect you from unfair blame and reduce the chance of higher premiums.

Change of address

It sounds silly, but if you move to a new neighborhood with a new zip code, your insurance rates may go up, even if nothing else about your life changes. This is because some areas have a greater risk than others, and insurance companies want to make sure that your premiums reflect that increased risk.

The Role of Credit Scores in Determining Car Insurance Premiums

Insurance companies review your credit score to assess the risk of insuring you. Drivers with strong credit scores receive lower rates. Insurers associate good credit with responsible behavior, including safe driving.

Poor credit, on the other hand, raises concerns about payment reliability and risk exposure. A lower credit score signals a higher likelihood of filing claims, leading to higher premiums. Insurers view this as a financial risk and adjust your rates accordingly.

To lower your insurance costs, focus on improving your credit. Pay bills on time, reduce debt, and avoid opening unnecessary credit accounts. These actions boost your credit score and signal lower risk to insurers, which can result in better rates.

What to Do if Your Rates Go Up

Car insurance rates can rise unexpectedly, leaving many drivers frustrated. But you’re not powerless. Several strategies exist to help lower costs and keep more money in your pocket. Here’s how to take control of your insurance rates.

Shop for better rates

Rates vary from one insurance company to another. Some insurers offer lower prices for the same coverage. Get quotes from multiple providers and compare them to find the best option.

Consider usage-based insurance

Usage-based insurance calculates premiums based on your driving habits. If you drive less frequently or practice safe driving, this option could lead to significant savings. Check if your insurer offers a usage-based program.

Ask about discounts

Many insurance companies offer discounts for safe driving, bundling policies, or installing anti-theft devices. Call your insurer to see if you qualify for any of these cost-saving opportunities.

Review and adjust your coverage

Take a close look at your current coverage. If you’re driving an older car, you might not need comprehensive collision coverage. Reducing unnecessary coverage can lower your monthly premiums. To learn more about how much coverage you need in South Carolina and the different types available to you, check out this blog.

Raise your deductible

Opting for a higher deductible reduces your monthly premium. But make sure you’re financially ready to pay the higher out-of-pocket cost if you file a claim.

Improve your credit score

In some states, including South Carolina, your credit score affects your insurance rate. Improving your score by paying down debts and paying bills on time could result in lower premiums.

Dispute fault determinations

If you’re blamed for an accident but believe the fault determination is wrong, you’re not out of options. A South Carolina car crash attorney can help you challenge the claim and prevent an unjust rate increase.

Drive safely and avoid claims

Traffic violations, DUIs, and at-fault accidents cause premiums to rise. You can maintain a lower rate over time by driving safely and avoiding claims. Insurers also reward safe driving through programs like accident forgiveness.

Car insurance rate increases aren’t always avoidable, but you have options. Stay proactive and review your policy regularly to avoid surprises.

The Role of Accident Forgiveness in Preventing Rate Hikes

Accident forgiveness stops your insurance rates from rising after your first at-fault accident. Instead of raising your premium, the insurer ignores the incident, protecting you from higher costs. This is a smart option for those who want more control over their insurance costs.

This benefit is often available to safe drivers through policy upgrades or as a reward for a clean driving record. Some insurers include it automatically, while others offer it for an extra fee.

Not all insurers offer accident forgiveness, and eligibility rules differ. Some require you to be claim-free for a certain period, while others offer it as a premium package. Check your policy or contact your insurer to see if you qualify.

How South Carolina’s At-Fault System Affects Your Insurance Rates

South Carolina uses an at-fault system for car accidents, determining who pays for damages by placing financial responsibility on the responsible driver. This system also influences future insurance premiums for drivers deemed at fault.

What makes South Carolina’s at-fault system unique?

Unlike no-fault states, South Carolina allows injured parties to pursue compensation from the driver who caused the accident. Insurance companies assign fault percentages to each driver involved in a crash and may raise rates accordingly.

A lawyer will explain the state’s modified comparative negligence rules and how they apply to your crash.

How fault affects your insurance premiums

When you’re partially or fully at fault for an accident, insurance companies adjust your rates based on that determination.

Here’s what happens:

  • Fault assignments are recorded: Insurance companies document fault determinations on your driving record, and this record directly influences your insurance premiums.
  • Fault percentage matters: Even a minor share of the blame—like 10% or 20%—could lead to higher premiums. Insurers view any at-fault designation as an indicator of risk.
  • Higher premiums for at-fault drivers: Drivers with at-fault accidents on their records are considered higher risk, often triggering a rate increase. This increase can remain in effect for several years, impacting long-term insurance costs.

South Carolina’s at-fault system significantly affects how insurance premiums are calculated. You can protect yourself from unnecessary rate increases by challenging inaccurate fault assignments and leveraging legal support. Taking steps to protect your driving record now could result in lower premiums.

How insurers track and use fault data

Insurance companies maintain records of every claim you’re involved in, and at-fault accidents stay on your record for several years. This data plays a key role in determining your risk level. Key points include:

  • Claims history reviews: Insurers review claims history when it’s time to renew or adjust a policy, and any at-fault accidents may result in higher rates.
  • Data sharing among insurers: Insurers often share claims data with each other through industry databases, so switching providers may not shield you from premium increases.

Fault determinations stay on your record, affect your ability to switch providers, and influence how insurers classify your risk.

Contact a Car Accident Attorney If You’re in a Wreck

Being found at fault for a car accident in South Carolina doesn’t just mean paying for damages—it’s also likely to raise your insurance premiums. On top of higher rates, you could be denied compensation for your own injuries and property damage due to your share of fault.

If you believe you’ve been unfairly blamed for an accident, you have options.

A South Carolina auto accident attorney from the Joye Law Firm can challenge the fault determination, protect your rights, and help you pursue the compensation you deserve.

Since 1968, Joye Law Firm has been a trusted advocate for personal injury clients across South Carolina. Our team of experienced attorneys have built a legacy of fighting for fair outcomes and just compensation for accident victims.

Joye Law Firm’s approach is centered on compassion and results. We understand the hardships accident victims face and provide personalized guidance every step of the way. From negotiating with insurers to litigating in court, we’re relentless in pursuing justice for our clients.

Call or reach out online to schedule a free consultation today.

About the Author

As a South Carolina trial lawyer I represent clients in a wide range of matters, from wrongful death, catastrophic personal injury, and premises liability cases to sexual harassment. I represent innocent people who have been wronged, and my role is to hold responsible parties accountable. A premises liability case arises when a powerful entity has knowledge of a defect that could needlessly cause physical harm or death, for example, a trip hazard or a fire hazard, but the entity fails to mitigate the risk by fixing the defect, by implementing a new procedure or simply warning of the risk.

Recent Blog Post
What Is the Exclusive Remedy Doctrine?

If you’re in the process of filing a workers’ compensation claim, you may have come across the term “exclusive remedy doctrine” and wondered, “What is the exclusive remedy doctrine, and how does it affect my case?” This principle is central…

Attorney taking notes
What Happens When You Reject an Insurance Settlement Offer?

Getting hurt because of someone else’s negligence can throw your life off track. Beyond the physical pain, you’re often left with mounting medical bills, lost wages, and uncertainty about what the future holds. When dealing with an insurance claim, it’s…

girl on the phone panicked standing beside her wrecked car
How Our Lawyers Handle an Allstate Injury Claim

Dealing with injuries from a car accident someone else caused can feel like a long, uphill battle. The pain and stress of recovery are challenging enough without the added frustration of dealing with insurance companies like Allstate. Unfortunately, Allstate, like…

Man being breathalyzed
What is Dram Shop Liability in South Carolina?

Alcohol-related accidents lead to devastating consequences, and holding the right parties accountable is crucial for justice. Dram shop and social host liability laws in South Carolina are designed to do just that. These laws hold businesses and individuals responsible when they…

Awards & Recognition
Media
ABC
NBC
Fox
CBS News
ESPN Radio logo